top of page
Positive LidERA? Hidden risks beneath the SERD surface
May 18, 2026
Our latest detailed adjuvant SERDs analsyis reveals a potential mispricing emerging between Roche and AstraZeneca, with the market potentially extrapolating lidERA into a broader commercial opportunity than is warranted, while underappreciating more practice-aligned pathways elsewhere. The core debate is whether investors should be underwriting a broad SERD backbone in early breast cancer today, or positioning for a narrower outcome with a different catalyst path into 2027 that could shift relative value across the group.
Key questions we address include:
-
What does the lidERA adjuvant SERD dataset actually establish in terms of clinical positioning within early breast cancer?
-
Is the market over-extrapolating early efficacy signals into broad commercial adoption across early breast cancer?
-
Where is the true clinical and commercial entry point for next-generation SERDs in the adjuvant setting?
-
How should investors frame the relative importance of emerging trial designs that align with current treatment paradigms?
-
Are current valuations appropriately reflecting probability-weighted outcomes across Roche, AstraZeneca, and the broader SERD class into upcoming catalysts?
Year | Stock | Call | Move |
|---|---|---|---|
2026 | Roche | Giredestrant persevERA fails in ITT | -5% |
2025 | BAY | OCEANIC-STROKE reduces stroke | +11% |
2025 | BMY | Factor IX reduces strokes | +4% |
2025 | MRK | MRK: Sotatercept: Pulmonary HT CADENCE-PH p2 positve | +4% |
2025 | MRK | Oral PCSK9 CORAL-reef LIPIDs P3 positve | +5% |
2025 | BMY | LIBREXIA-ACS trial missed | -4% |
2025 | NOVN | Oral Fablata eGFR benefit leave inj BAFF/APRIL's undifferentiated | +2% |
2025 | ROG | ROG: Giredestrant evERA P3 PFS driven by ESR1 benefit only | -2% |
2025 | NOVN | Remibrutinib FDA approved | +3% |
2025 | NOVN | Successful phase III NEPTUNUS | +4% |
2025 | VERA | ORIGIN3 well ahead of expectations | +68% |
2025 | NOVN | P3 APPULSE +ve switch from C5 inc Hb by 2 | +2% |
2024 | BMY | Cendakimab: eosinophilic oesophagitis P3 positve | +4% |
2024 | AZN | Dato-DXD misses OS in Lung and Breast | -12% |
2024 | SRPT | Wide label FDA approval of Duchenne Gene Rx | +52% |
2024 | CYTK | Royalty deal, not Buy out | -33% |
2024 | MRK | FDA approval of Pulmonary HT drug | +5% |
2023 | Pfizer | FDA approval of Hair loss drug | +2% |
2023 | Novartis | Kisqali wins in early stage breast cancer | +25% |
2023 | MRK | TIGIT fails | -5% |
2023 | CNCE | Alopeica BuyOut | +186% |
2022 | ROG | TIGIT fails | -5% |
2022 | AZN | Lynparza positive phase III in prostate cancer | +5% |
2021 | Novartis | Unprecedented OS from Kisqali in all breast cancer | +4% |
2021 | BMY | Successful Factor XIa blot clot prevention trial | +2% |
2021 | GSK | Best in class CKD phase III | +2% |
2021 | JNJ | Legend BCMA FDA delay | -3% |
2021 | BMY | Abecma FDA approval | +4% |
2021 | JNJ | Amivantamab FDA approval | +2% |
2020 | BMY | FDA approval of Ipi+nivo with best OS ever | +3% |
2020 | Novartis | Zolgensma best in class data in SMA | +5% |
2019 | MRK | CM227 better long term survival than MRK | -6% |
2019 | Bristol | CHECKMATE 227 meets OS | +6% |
2018 | Incyte | NKTR-214 misses ORR expectation at SITIC | +51% |
2018 | Incyte | IDO fails | -52% |
2017 | Bristol | IO/IO combo successful in Kidney cancer | +5% |
2017 | Puma | Neratinib FDA approval | +200% |
2017 | Roche | Perjeta fails in majority of APHINITY | -9% |
2016 | Bristol | Opdivo fails in 1st line Lung cancer | -20% |
2015 | Bristol | Opdivo benefit restricted in 2L Lung cancer | -8% |
2014 | Roche | TDM1 fails | -7% |
2014 | Roche | MetMab fails | -5% |
2013 | Novo | Levmir pricing | +20% |
2013 | Novo | FDA rejects degludec | -13% |
2012 | Roche | dalcetrapib fails | -7% |
2011 | Roche | Avastin formally withdrawn breast | -5% |
2010 | Astra | FDA rejects Brillinta | -11% |
2010 | Roche | Avastin Breast 2nd ODAC | -10% |
2010 | Novartis | Gilenya FDA approved | +7% |
2010 | Novartis | Unanimous +ve ODAC Gilenya | +7% |
2009 | Sanofi | Prescribing ignored Lantus scare | +20% |
2009 | Roche | Avastin fails early colon cancer | -13% |
2008 | Roche | Avastin thesis | -30% |
2007 | Roche | Avastin Breast ODAC | -9% |
2007 | Sanofi | Acomplia ODAC | -13% |
2006 | Sanofi | Plavix generic FTC | -9% |
Dr Amit Roy, Founding Partner
Dr Roy has been serving the Hedge Fund and Mutual Fund community for 20 years with bold, contrarian research, founding Foveal LLP in 2014.
After graduating from the University of Cambridge and gaining Membership of the Royal College of Surgeons, he became one of the youngest Cardio-Thoracic surgeons in the U.K. He developed a unique insight into the drivers of drug safety and pharmaceutical risk assessment during his years in R&D at Roche Pharmaceuticals, while gaining an MBA from London Business School. Amit was a Managing Director at Nomura and head of European Healthcare Equity Research since 2008, having joined from Citigroup. He has delivered a consistent, strong track record of predicting the outcomes of key catalysts and value drivers in the biotech & pharma sectors for over 20 years, yielding persistent alpha for his clients.
bottom of page